intel/blorp: Refactor the HiZ op interface
[mesa.git] / src / mesa / drivers / dri / i965 / brw_blorp.c
index 8020a95f52dfdf692c4361e76d1eb5d8ff58dc2b..834f43249a9551789a403cbdfae58853a15e12cd 100644 (file)
@@ -34,7 +34,7 @@
 #include "brw_meta_util.h"
 #include "brw_state.h"
 #include "intel_fbo.h"
-#include "intel_debug.h"
+#include "common/gen_debug.h"
 
 #define FILE_DEBUG_FLAG DEBUG_BLORP
 
@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@ brw_blorp_lookup_shader(struct blorp_context *blorp,
                            key, key_size, kernel_out, prog_data_out);
 }
 
-static void
+static bool
 brw_blorp_upload_shader(struct blorp_context *blorp,
                         const void *key, uint32_t key_size,
                         const void *kernel, uint32_t kernel_size,
@@ -60,6 +60,7 @@ brw_blorp_upload_shader(struct blorp_context *blorp,
    brw_upload_cache(&brw->cache, BRW_CACHE_BLORP_PROG, key, key_size,
                     kernel, kernel_size, prog_data, prog_data_size,
                     kernel_out, prog_data_out);
+   return true;
 }
 
 void
@@ -70,6 +71,16 @@ brw_blorp_init(struct brw_context *brw)
    brw->blorp.compiler = brw->screen->compiler;
 
    switch (brw->gen) {
+   case 4:
+      if (brw->is_g4x) {
+         brw->blorp.exec = gen45_blorp_exec;
+      } else {
+         brw->blorp.exec = gen4_blorp_exec;
+      }
+      break;
+   case 5:
+      brw->blorp.exec = gen5_blorp_exec;
+      break;
    case 6:
       brw->blorp.mocs.tex = 0;
       brw->blorp.mocs.rb = 0;
@@ -106,36 +117,6 @@ brw_blorp_init(struct brw_context *brw)
    brw->blorp.upload_shader = brw_blorp_upload_shader;
 }
 
-static void
-apply_gen6_stencil_hiz_offset(struct isl_surf *surf,
-                              struct intel_mipmap_tree *mt,
-                              uint32_t lod,
-                              uint32_t *offset)
-{
-   assert(mt->array_layout == ALL_SLICES_AT_EACH_LOD);
-
-   if (mt->format == MESA_FORMAT_S_UINT8) {
-      /* Note: we can't compute the stencil offset using
-       * intel_miptree_get_aligned_offset(), because the miptree
-       * claims that the region is untiled even though it's W tiled.
-       */
-      *offset = mt->level[lod].level_y * mt->pitch +
-                mt->level[lod].level_x * 64;
-   } else {
-      *offset = intel_miptree_get_aligned_offset(mt,
-                                                 mt->level[lod].level_x,
-                                                 mt->level[lod].level_y);
-   }
-
-   surf->logical_level0_px.width = minify(surf->logical_level0_px.width, lod);
-   surf->logical_level0_px.height = minify(surf->logical_level0_px.height, lod);
-   surf->phys_level0_sa.width = minify(surf->phys_level0_sa.width, lod);
-   surf->phys_level0_sa.height = minify(surf->phys_level0_sa.height, lod);
-   surf->levels = 1;
-   surf->array_pitch_el_rows =
-      ALIGN(surf->phys_level0_sa.height, surf->image_alignment_el.height);
-}
-
 static void
 blorp_surf_for_miptree(struct brw_context *brw,
                        struct blorp_surf *surf,
@@ -170,24 +151,6 @@ blorp_surf_for_miptree(struct brw_context *brw,
       .write_domain = is_render_target ? I915_GEM_DOMAIN_RENDER : 0,
    };
 
-   if (brw->gen == 6 && mt->format == MESA_FORMAT_S_UINT8 &&
-       mt->array_layout == ALL_SLICES_AT_EACH_LOD) {
-      /* Sandy bridge stencil and HiZ use this ALL_SLICES_AT_EACH_LOD hack in
-       * order to allow for layered rendering.  The hack makes each LOD of the
-       * stencil or HiZ buffer a single tightly packed array surface at some
-       * offset into the surface.  Since ISL doesn't know how to deal with the
-       * crazy ALL_SLICES_AT_EACH_LOD layout and since we have to do a manual
-       * offset of it anyway, we might as well do the offset here and keep the
-       * hacks inside the i965 driver.
-       *
-       * See also gen6_depth_stencil_state.c
-       */
-      uint32_t offset;
-      apply_gen6_stencil_hiz_offset(&tmp_surfs[0], mt, *level, &offset);
-      surf->addr.offset += offset;
-      *level = 0;
-   }
-
    struct isl_surf *aux_surf = &tmp_surfs[1];
    intel_miptree_get_aux_isl_surf(brw, mt, aux_surf, &surf->aux_usage);
 
@@ -216,19 +179,21 @@ blorp_surf_for_miptree(struct brw_context *brw,
          intel_miptree_resolve_color(brw, mt,
                                      *level, start_layer, num_layers, flags);
 
-         assert(mt->fast_clear_state == INTEL_FAST_CLEAR_STATE_RESOLVED);
+         assert(!intel_miptree_has_color_unresolved(mt, *level, 1,
+                                                    start_layer, num_layers));
          surf->aux_usage = ISL_AUX_USAGE_NONE;
       }
    }
 
    if (is_render_target)
-      intel_miptree_used_for_rendering(brw, mt);
+      intel_miptree_used_for_rendering(brw, mt, *level,
+                                       start_layer, num_layers);
 
    if (surf->aux_usage != ISL_AUX_USAGE_NONE) {
       /* We only really need a clear color if we also have an auxiliary
        * surface.  Without one, it does nothing.
        */
-      surf->clear_color = intel_miptree_get_isl_clear_color(brw, mt);
+      surf->clear_color = mt->fast_clear_color;
 
       surf->aux_surf = aux_surf;
       surf->aux_addr = (struct blorp_address) {
@@ -242,25 +207,9 @@ blorp_surf_for_miptree(struct brw_context *brw,
          surf->aux_addr.offset = mt->mcs_buf->offset;
       } else {
          assert(surf->aux_usage == ISL_AUX_USAGE_HIZ);
-         struct intel_mipmap_tree *hiz_mt = mt->hiz_buf->mt;
-         if (hiz_mt) {
-            surf->aux_addr.buffer = hiz_mt->bo;
-            if (brw->gen == 6 &&
-                hiz_mt->array_layout == ALL_SLICES_AT_EACH_LOD) {
-               /* gen6 requires the HiZ buffer to be manually offset to the
-                * right location.  We could fixup the surf but it doesn't
-                * matter since most of those fields don't matter.
-                */
-               apply_gen6_stencil_hiz_offset(aux_surf, hiz_mt, *level,
-                                             &surf->aux_addr.offset);
-            } else {
-               surf->aux_addr.offset = 0;
-            }
-            assert(hiz_mt->pitch == aux_surf->row_pitch);
-         } else {
-            surf->aux_addr.buffer = mt->hiz_buf->aux_base.bo;
-            surf->aux_addr.offset = mt->hiz_buf->aux_base.offset;
-         }
+
+         surf->aux_addr.buffer = mt->hiz_buf->aux_base.bo;
+         surf->aux_addr.offset = mt->hiz_buf->aux_base.offset;
       }
    } else {
       surf->aux_addr = (struct blorp_address) {
@@ -270,6 +219,9 @@ blorp_surf_for_miptree(struct brw_context *brw,
    }
    assert((surf->aux_usage == ISL_AUX_USAGE_NONE) ==
           (surf->aux_addr.buffer == NULL));
+
+   /* ISL wants real levels, not offset ones. */
+   *level -= mt->first_level;
 }
 
 static enum isl_format
@@ -282,8 +234,10 @@ brw_blorp_to_isl_format(struct brw_context *brw, mesa_format format,
    case MESA_FORMAT_S_UINT8:
       return ISL_FORMAT_R8_UINT;
    case MESA_FORMAT_Z24_UNORM_X8_UINT:
+   case MESA_FORMAT_Z24_UNORM_S8_UINT:
       return ISL_FORMAT_R24_UNORM_X8_TYPELESS;
    case MESA_FORMAT_Z_FLOAT32:
+   case MESA_FORMAT_Z32_FLOAT_S8X24_UINT:
       return ISL_FORMAT_R32_FLOAT;
    case MESA_FORMAT_Z_UNORM16:
       return ISL_FORMAT_R16_UNORM;
@@ -292,7 +246,7 @@ brw_blorp_to_isl_format(struct brw_context *brw, mesa_format format,
          assert(brw->format_supported_as_render_target[format]);
          return brw->render_target_format[format];
       } else {
-         return brw_format_for_mesa_format(format);
+         return brw_isl_format_for_mesa_format(format);
       }
       break;
    }
@@ -568,12 +522,25 @@ try_blorp_blit(struct brw_context *brw,
           (dst_mt->format == MESA_FORMAT_Z24_UNORM_X8_UINT))
          return false;
 
+      /* We also can't handle any combined depth-stencil formats because we
+       * have to reinterpret as a color format.
+       */
+      if (_mesa_get_format_base_format(src_mt->format) == GL_DEPTH_STENCIL ||
+          _mesa_get_format_base_format(dst_mt->format) == GL_DEPTH_STENCIL)
+         return false;
+
       do_blorp_blit(brw, buffer_bit, src_irb, MESA_FORMAT_NONE,
                     dst_irb, MESA_FORMAT_NONE, srcX0, srcY0,
                     srcX1, srcY1, dstX0, dstY0, dstX1, dstY1,
                     filter, mirror_x, mirror_y);
       break;
    case GL_STENCIL_BUFFER_BIT:
+      /* Blorp doesn't support combined depth stencil which is all we have
+       * prior to gen6.
+       */
+      if (brw->gen < 6)
+         return false;
+
       src_irb =
          intel_renderbuffer(read_fb->Attachment[BUFFER_STENCIL].Renderbuffer);
       dst_irb =
@@ -619,10 +586,6 @@ brw_blorp_copytexsubimage(struct brw_context *brw,
    if (src_mt->num_samples > 8 || dst_mt->num_samples > 8)
       return false;
 
-   /* BLORP is only supported from Gen6 onwards. */
-   if (brw->gen < 6)
-      return false;
-
    if (_mesa_get_format_base_format(src_rb->Format) !=
        _mesa_get_format_base_format(dst_image->TexFormat)) {
       return false;
@@ -637,6 +600,13 @@ brw_blorp_copytexsubimage(struct brw_context *brw,
       return false;
    }
 
+   /* We also can't handle any combined depth-stencil formats because we
+    * have to reinterpret as a color format.
+    */
+   if (_mesa_get_format_base_format(src_mt->format) == GL_DEPTH_STENCIL ||
+       _mesa_get_format_base_format(dst_mt->format) == GL_DEPTH_STENCIL)
+      return false;
+
    if (!brw->format_supported_as_render_target[dst_image->TexFormat])
       return false;
 
@@ -721,10 +691,6 @@ brw_blorp_framebuffer(struct brw_context *brw,
                       GLint dstX0, GLint dstY0, GLint dstX1, GLint dstY1,
                       GLbitfield mask, GLenum filter)
 {
-   /* BLORP is not supported before Gen6. */
-   if (brw->gen < 6)
-      return mask;
-
    static GLbitfield buffer_bits[] = {
       GL_COLOR_BUFFER_BIT,
       GL_DEPTH_BUFFER_BIT,
@@ -806,38 +772,43 @@ do_single_blorp_clear(struct brw_context *brw, struct gl_framebuffer *fb,
    if (set_write_disables(irb, ctx->Color.ColorMask[buf], color_write_disable))
       can_fast_clear = false;
 
-   if (irb->mt->fast_clear_state == INTEL_FAST_CLEAR_STATE_NO_MCS ||
+   if (irb->mt->aux_disable & INTEL_AUX_DISABLE_CCS ||
        !brw_is_color_fast_clear_compatible(brw, irb->mt, &ctx->Color.ClearColor))
       can_fast_clear = false;
 
-   const bool is_lossless_compressed = intel_miptree_is_lossless_compressed(
-                                          brw, irb->mt);
+   const unsigned logical_layer = irb_logical_mt_layer(irb);
+   const enum intel_fast_clear_state fast_clear_state =
+      intel_miptree_get_fast_clear_state(irb->mt, irb->mt_level,
+                                         logical_layer);
+
+   /* Surface state can only record one fast clear color value. Therefore
+    * unless different levels/layers agree on the color it can be used to
+    * represent only single level/layer. Here it will be reserved for the
+    * first slice (level 0, layer 0).
+    */
+   if (irb->layer_count > 1 || irb->mt_level || irb->mt_layer)
+      can_fast_clear = false;
 
    if (can_fast_clear) {
-      union gl_color_union override_color =
+      union isl_color_value clear_color =
          brw_meta_convert_fast_clear_color(brw, irb->mt,
                                            &ctx->Color.ClearColor);
 
-      /* Record the clear color in the miptree so that it will be
-       * programmed in SURFACE_STATE by later rendering and resolve
-       * operations.
-       */
-      const bool color_updated = brw_meta_set_fast_clear_color(
-                                    brw, &irb->mt->gen9_fast_clear_color,
-                                    &override_color);
-
       /* If the buffer is already in INTEL_FAST_CLEAR_STATE_CLEAR, the clear
        * is redundant and can be skipped.
        */
-      if (!color_updated &&
-          irb->mt->fast_clear_state == INTEL_FAST_CLEAR_STATE_CLEAR)
+      if (fast_clear_state == INTEL_FAST_CLEAR_STATE_CLEAR &&
+          memcmp(&irb->mt->fast_clear_color,
+                 &clear_color, sizeof(clear_color)) == 0)
          return true;
 
+      irb->mt->fast_clear_color = clear_color;
+
       /* If the MCS buffer hasn't been allocated yet, we need to allocate
        * it now.
        */
       if (!irb->mt->mcs_buf) {
-         assert(!is_lossless_compressed);
+         assert(!intel_miptree_is_lossless_compressed(brw, irb->mt));
          if (!intel_miptree_alloc_non_msrt_mcs(brw, irb->mt, false)) {
             /* MCS allocation failed--probably this will only happen in
              * out-of-memory conditions.  But in any case, try to recover
@@ -848,7 +819,6 @@ do_single_blorp_clear(struct brw_context *brw, struct gl_framebuffer *fb,
       }
    }
 
-   const unsigned logical_layer = irb_logical_mt_layer(irb);
    const unsigned num_layers = fb->MaxNumLayers ? irb->layer_count : 1;
 
    /* We can't setup the blorp_surf until we've allocated the MCS above */
@@ -865,19 +835,41 @@ do_single_blorp_clear(struct brw_context *brw, struct gl_framebuffer *fb,
       DBG("%s (fast) to mt %p level %d layers %d+%d\n", __FUNCTION__,
           irb->mt, irb->mt_level, irb->mt_layer, num_layers);
 
+      /* Ivybrigde PRM Vol 2, Part 1, "11.7 MCS Buffer for Render Target(s)":
+       *
+       *    "Any transition from any value in {Clear, Render, Resolve} to a
+       *    different value in {Clear, Render, Resolve} requires end of pipe
+       *    synchronization."
+       *
+       * In other words, fast clear ops are not properly synchronized with
+       * other drawing.  We need to use a PIPE_CONTROL to ensure that the
+       * contents of the previous draw hit the render target before we resolve
+       * and again afterwards to ensure that the resolve is complete before we
+       * do any more regular drawing.
+       */
+      brw_emit_pipe_control_flush(brw,
+                                  PIPE_CONTROL_RENDER_TARGET_FLUSH |
+                                  PIPE_CONTROL_CS_STALL);
+
       struct blorp_batch batch;
       blorp_batch_init(&brw->blorp, &batch, brw, 0);
       blorp_fast_clear(&batch, &surf,
-                       (enum isl_format)brw->render_target_format[format],
+                       brw->render_target_format[format],
                        level, logical_layer, num_layers,
                        x0, y0, x1, y1);
       blorp_batch_finish(&batch);
 
+      brw_emit_pipe_control_flush(brw,
+                                  PIPE_CONTROL_RENDER_TARGET_FLUSH |
+                                  PIPE_CONTROL_CS_STALL);
+
       /* Now that the fast clear has occurred, put the buffer in
        * INTEL_FAST_CLEAR_STATE_CLEAR so that we won't waste time doing
        * redundant clears.
        */
-      irb->mt->fast_clear_state = INTEL_FAST_CLEAR_STATE_CLEAR;
+      intel_miptree_set_fast_clear_state(brw, irb->mt, irb->mt_level,
+                                         logical_layer, num_layers,
+                                         INTEL_FAST_CLEAR_STATE_CLEAR);
    } else {
       DBG("%s (slow) to mt %p level %d layer %d+%d\n", __FUNCTION__,
           irb->mt, irb->mt_level, irb->mt_layer, num_layers);
@@ -888,7 +880,7 @@ do_single_blorp_clear(struct brw_context *brw, struct gl_framebuffer *fb,
       struct blorp_batch batch;
       blorp_batch_init(&brw->blorp, &batch, brw, 0);
       blorp_clear(&batch, &surf,
-                  (enum isl_format)brw->render_target_format[format],
+                  brw->render_target_format[format],
                   ISL_SWIZZLE_IDENTITY,
                   level, irb_logical_mt_layer(irb), num_layers,
                   x0, y0, x1, y1,
@@ -957,6 +949,23 @@ brw_blorp_resolve_color(struct brw_context *brw, struct intel_mipmap_tree *mt,
       resolve_op = BLORP_FAST_CLEAR_OP_RESOLVE_FULL;
    }
 
+   /* Ivybrigde PRM Vol 2, Part 1, "11.7 MCS Buffer for Render Target(s)":
+    *
+    *    "Any transition from any value in {Clear, Render, Resolve} to a
+    *    different value in {Clear, Render, Resolve} requires end of pipe
+    *    synchronization."
+    *
+    * In other words, fast clear ops are not properly synchronized with
+    * other drawing.  We need to use a PIPE_CONTROL to ensure that the
+    * contents of the previous draw hit the render target before we resolve
+    * and again afterwards to ensure that the resolve is complete before we
+    * do any more regular drawing.
+    */
+   brw_emit_pipe_control_flush(brw,
+                               PIPE_CONTROL_RENDER_TARGET_FLUSH |
+                               PIPE_CONTROL_CS_STALL);
+
+
    struct blorp_batch batch;
    blorp_batch_init(&brw->blorp, &batch, brw, 0);
    blorp_ccs_resolve(&batch, &surf, level, layer,
@@ -964,24 +973,10 @@ brw_blorp_resolve_color(struct brw_context *brw, struct intel_mipmap_tree *mt,
                      resolve_op);
    blorp_batch_finish(&batch);
 
-   mt->fast_clear_state = INTEL_FAST_CLEAR_STATE_RESOLVED;
-}
-
-static void
-gen6_blorp_hiz_exec(struct brw_context *brw, struct intel_mipmap_tree *mt,
-                    unsigned int level, unsigned int layer, enum blorp_hiz_op op)
-{
-   assert(intel_miptree_level_has_hiz(mt, level));
-
-   struct isl_surf isl_tmp[2];
-   struct blorp_surf surf;
-   blorp_surf_for_miptree(brw, &surf, mt, true, (1 << ISL_AUX_USAGE_HIZ),
-                          &level, layer, 1, isl_tmp);
-
-   struct blorp_batch batch;
-   blorp_batch_init(&brw->blorp, &batch, brw, 0);
-   blorp_gen6_hiz_op(&batch, &surf, level, layer, op);
-   blorp_batch_finish(&batch);
+   /* See comment above */
+   brw_emit_pipe_control_flush(brw,
+                               PIPE_CONTROL_RENDER_TARGET_FLUSH |
+                               PIPE_CONTROL_CS_STALL);
 }
 
 /**
@@ -995,7 +990,8 @@ gen6_blorp_hiz_exec(struct brw_context *brw, struct intel_mipmap_tree *mt,
  */
 void
 intel_hiz_exec(struct brw_context *brw, struct intel_mipmap_tree *mt,
-              unsigned int level, unsigned int layer, enum blorp_hiz_op op)
+               unsigned int level, unsigned int start_layer,
+               unsigned int num_layers, enum blorp_hiz_op op)
 {
    const char *opname = NULL;
 
@@ -1014,12 +1010,94 @@ intel_hiz_exec(struct brw_context *brw, struct intel_mipmap_tree *mt,
       break;
    }
 
-   DBG("%s %s to mt %p level %d layer %d\n",
-       __func__, opname, mt, level, layer);
+   DBG("%s %s to mt %p level %d layers %d-%d\n",
+       __func__, opname, mt, level, start_layer, start_layer + num_layers - 1);
+
+   /* The following stalls and flushes are only documented to be required for
+    * HiZ clear operations.  However, they also seem to be required for the
+    * HiZ resolve operation which is basically the same as a fast clear only a
+    * different value is written into the HiZ surface.
+    */
+   if (op == BLORP_HIZ_OP_DEPTH_CLEAR || op == BLORP_HIZ_OP_HIZ_RESOLVE) {
+      if (brw->gen == 6) {
+         /* From the Sandy Bridge PRM, volume 2 part 1, page 313:
+          *
+          *   "If other rendering operations have preceded this clear, a
+          *   PIPE_CONTROL with write cache flush enabled and Z-inhibit
+          *   disabled must be issued before the rectangle primitive used for
+          *   the depth buffer clear operation.
+          */
+          brw_emit_pipe_control_flush(brw,
+                                      PIPE_CONTROL_RENDER_TARGET_FLUSH |
+                                      PIPE_CONTROL_DEPTH_CACHE_FLUSH |
+                                      PIPE_CONTROL_CS_STALL);
+      } else if (brw->gen >= 7) {
+         /*
+          * From the Ivybridge PRM, volume 2, "Depth Buffer Clear":
+          *
+          *   If other rendering operations have preceded this clear, a
+          *   PIPE_CONTROL with depth cache flush enabled, Depth Stall bit
+          *   enabled must be issued before the rectangle primitive used for
+          *   the depth buffer clear operation.
+          *
+          * Same applies for Gen8 and Gen9.
+          *
+          * In addition, from the Ivybridge PRM, volume 2, 1.10.4.1
+          * PIPE_CONTROL, Depth Cache Flush Enable:
+          *
+          *   This bit must not be set when Depth Stall Enable bit is set in
+          *   this packet.
+          *
+          * This is confirmed to hold for real, HSW gets immediate gpu hangs.
+          *
+          * Therefore issue two pipe control flushes, one for cache flush and
+          * another for depth stall.
+          */
+          brw_emit_pipe_control_flush(brw,
+                                      PIPE_CONTROL_DEPTH_CACHE_FLUSH |
+                                      PIPE_CONTROL_CS_STALL);
+
+          brw_emit_pipe_control_flush(brw, PIPE_CONTROL_DEPTH_STALL);
+      }
+   }
 
    if (brw->gen >= 8) {
-      gen8_hiz_exec(brw, mt, level, layer, op);
+      for (unsigned a = 0; a < num_layers; a++)
+         gen8_hiz_exec(brw, mt, level, start_layer + a, op);
    } else {
-      gen6_blorp_hiz_exec(brw, mt, level, layer, op);
+      assert(intel_miptree_level_has_hiz(mt, level));
+
+      struct isl_surf isl_tmp[2];
+      struct blorp_surf surf;
+      blorp_surf_for_miptree(brw, &surf, mt, true, (1 << ISL_AUX_USAGE_HIZ),
+                             &level, start_layer, num_layers, isl_tmp);
+
+      struct blorp_batch batch;
+      blorp_batch_init(&brw->blorp, &batch, brw, 0);
+      blorp_hiz_op(&batch, &surf, level, start_layer, num_layers, op);
+      blorp_batch_finish(&batch);
+   }
+
+
+   /* The following stalls and flushes are only documented to be required for
+    * HiZ clear operations.  However, they also seem to be required for the
+    * HiZ resolve operation which is basically the same as a fast clear only a
+    * different value is written into the HiZ surface.
+    */
+   if (op == BLORP_HIZ_OP_DEPTH_CLEAR || op == BLORP_HIZ_OP_HIZ_RESOLVE) {
+      if (brw->gen == 6) {
+         /* From the Sandy Bridge PRM, volume 2 part 1, page 314:
+          *
+          *     "DevSNB, DevSNB-B{W/A}]: Depth buffer clear pass must be
+          *     followed by a PIPE_CONTROL command with DEPTH_STALL bit set
+          *     and Then followed by Depth FLUSH'
+         */
+         brw_emit_pipe_control_flush(brw,
+                                     PIPE_CONTROL_DEPTH_STALL);
+
+         brw_emit_pipe_control_flush(brw,
+                                     PIPE_CONTROL_DEPTH_CACHE_FLUSH |
+                                     PIPE_CONTROL_CS_STALL);
+      }
    }
 }