x86: Fix vextract* masked patterns [PR93069]
The AVX512F documentation clearly states that in instructions where the
destination is a memory only merging-masking is possible, not zero-masking,
and the assembler enforces that.
The testcase in this patch fails to assemble because of
Error: unsupported masking for `vextracti32x8'
on
vextracti32x8 $0x0, %zmm1, -64(%rsp){%k1}{z}
For the vector extraction patterns, we apparently have 7 *_maskm patterns
that only accept memory destinations and rtx_equal_p merge-masking source
for it, 7 *<mask_name> corresponding patterns that allow memory destination
only for the non-masked cases (through <store_mask_constraint>), then 2
*<mask_name> patterns (lo ssehalf V16FI and lo ssehalf VI8F_256 ones) which
do allow memory destination even for masked cases and are the cause of the
testsuite failure, because we must not allow C constraint if the destination
is m, and finally one pair of patterns (separate * and *_mask, hi ssehalf
VI4F_256), which has another issue (for which I don't have a testcase
though), where if it would match zero-masking with register destination,
it wouldn't emit the needed {z} into assembly.
The attached patch fixes those 3 issues only, perhaps more suitable for
backporting.
But, even with that fixed, we are missing 3 further *_maskm patterns and
more importantly, I find the split into 3 separate patterns after subst,
*_maskm for masking with memory destination, *_mask for masking with
register destination and * for non-masking unnecessarily complex and harder
for reload, so the included patch below (non-attached) instead kills all
*_maskm patterns and splits the *<mask_name> patterns into * and *_mask
by hand instead of subst, where the *_mask ones make sure that with v
destination they use 0C, while with m destination they use 0 and as
condition enforce that either destination is not MEM, or rtx_equal_p between
the destination and corresponding merging-masking operand source.
If we had those 3 missing *_maskm patterns, this patch would actually result
in both shorter sse.md and shorter machine description after subst (e.g.
length of tmp-mddump.md), as we don't have them, the patch is actually 16
lines longer sse.md, but still shorter tmp-mddump.md.
2020-05-06 Jakub Jelinek <jakub@redhat.com>
PR target/93069
* config/i386/subst.md (store_mask_constraint, store_mask_predicate):
Remove.
(avx512dq_vextract<shuffletype>64x2_1_maskm,
avx512f_vextract<shuffletype>32x4_1_maskm,
vec_extract_lo_<mode>_maskm, vec_extract_hi_<mode>_maskm): Remove.
(<mask_codefor>avx512dq_vextract<shuffletype>64x2_1<mask_name>): Split
into ...
(*avx512dq_vextract<shuffletype>64x2_1,
avx512dq_vextract<shuffletype>64x2_1_mask): ... these new
define_insns. Even in the masked variant allow memory output but in
that case use 0 rather than 0C constraint on the source of masked-out
elts.
(<mask_codefor>avx512f_vextract<shuffletype>32x4_1<mask_name>): Split
into ...
(*avx512f_vextract<shuffletype>32x4_1,
avx512f_vextract<shuffletype>32x4_1_mask): ... these new define_insns.
Even in the masked variant allow memory output but in that case use
0 rather than 0C constraint on the source of masked-out elts.
(vec_extract_lo_<mode><mask_name>): Split into ...
(vec_extract_lo_<mode>, vec_extract_lo_<mode>_mask): ... these new
define_insns. Even in the masked variant allow memory output but in
that case use 0 rather than 0C constraint on the source of masked-out
elts.
(vec_extract_hi_<mode><mask_name>): Split into ...
(vec_extract_hi_<mode>, vec_extract_hi_<mode>_mask): ... these new
define_insns. Even in the masked variant allow memory output but in
that case use 0 rather than 0C constraint on the source of masked-out
elts.