c-parse.in (all_prefix_attributes): New variable.

	* c-parse.in (all_prefix_attributes): New variable.
	(PUSH_DECLSPEC_STACK, POP_DECLSPEC_STACK): New macros.
	(maybe_resetattrs): New production.
	(c_parse_init, datadef, fndef, datadecl, setspecs, setattrs, decl,
	maybe_type_quals_setattrs, initdecls, notype_initdecls, initdcl,
	notype_initdcl, nested_function, notype_nested_function,
	component_decl, components, components_notype,
	component_declarator, component_notype_declarator,
	absdcl_maybe_attribute, parm, firstparm, setspecs_fp, ivar_decl,
	ivars, mydecl, myparm): Update.  Avoid prefix attributes just
	after a comma being applied to more than one declarator.
	* doc/extend.texi (Attribute Syntax): Update.  Remove
	documentation of bugs that are no longer present.

testsuite:
	* gcc.c-torture/compile/20010714-1.c, gcc.dg/format/attr-4.c: New
	tests.

From-SVN: r44070

diff --git a/gcc/ChangeLog b/gcc/ChangeLog
index e85b9704558c4baf39d21ffa6500fae7738b7bab..48466608a65518da48ec7a8d23b3bae25bab4e42 100644 (file)
--- a/gcc/ChangeLog
+++ b/gcc/ChangeLog
@@ -1,3 +1,19 @@
+2001-07-17  Joseph S. Myers  <jsm28@cam.ac.uk>
+
+       * c-parse.in (all_prefix_attributes): New variable.
+       (PUSH_DECLSPEC_STACK, POP_DECLSPEC_STACK): New macros.
+       (maybe_resetattrs): New production.
+       (c_parse_init, datadef, fndef, datadecl, setspecs, setattrs, decl,
+       maybe_type_quals_setattrs, initdecls, notype_initdecls, initdcl,
+       notype_initdcl, nested_function, notype_nested_function,
+       component_decl, components, components_notype,
+       component_declarator, component_notype_declarator,
+       absdcl_maybe_attribute, parm, firstparm, setspecs_fp, ivar_decl,
+       ivars, mydecl, myparm): Update.  Avoid prefix attributes just
+       after a comma being applied to more than one declarator.
+       * doc/extend.texi (Attribute Syntax): Update.  Remove
+       documentation of bugs that are no longer present.
+
 2001-07-13  Eric Christopher  <echristo@redhat.com>
 
        * config/mips/mips.h: Change TUNE_MIPS* options to use

diff --git a/gcc/c-parse.in b/gcc/c-parse.in
index a094ebb146f21bc6e90bf1561ebe200c97bc0d6d..d33a8c56b487f7e27cb755608f3ad4d3c2ed5df7 100644 (file)
--- a/gcc/c-parse.in
+++ b/gcc/c-parse.in
@@ -244,9 +244,33 @@ static int if_stmt_line;
 static tree current_declspecs = NULL_TREE;
 static tree prefix_attributes = NULL_TREE;
 
-/* Stack of saved values of current_declspecs and prefix_attributes.  */
+/* List of all the attributes applying to the identifier currently being
+   declared; includes prefix_attributes and possibly some more attributes
+   just after a comma.  */
+static tree all_prefix_attributes = NULL_TREE;
+
+/* Stack of saved values of current_declspecs, prefix_attributes and
+   all_prefix_attributes.  */
 static tree declspec_stack;
 
+/* PUSH_DECLSPEC_STACK is called from setspecs; POP_DECLSPEC_STACK
+   should be called from the productions making use of setspecs.  */
+#define PUSH_DECLSPEC_STACK                                             \
+  do {                                                                  \
+    declspec_stack = tree_cons (build_tree_list (prefix_attributes,     \
+                                                all_prefix_attributes), \
+                               current_declspecs,                       \
+                               declspec_stack);                         \
+  } while (0)
+
+#define POP_DECLSPEC_STACK                                             \
+  do {                                                                 \
+    current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);                   \
+    prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack));  \
+    all_prefix_attributes = TREE_VALUE (TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack));        \
+    declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack);                      \
+  } while (0)
+
 /* For __extension__, save/restore the warning flags which are
    controlled by __extension__.  */
 #define SAVE_WARN_FLAGS()      \
@@ -291,6 +315,7 @@ c_parse_init ()
   ggc_add_tree_root (&declspec_stack, 1);
   ggc_add_tree_root (&current_declspecs, 1);
   ggc_add_tree_root (&prefix_attributes, 1);
+  ggc_add_tree_root (&all_prefix_attributes, 1);
 ifobjc
   ggc_add_tree_root (&objc_interface_context, 1);
   ggc_add_tree_root (&objc_implementation_context, 1);
@@ -355,17 +380,11 @@ datadef:
                  else if (!flag_traditional)
                    warning ("data definition has no type or storage class"); 
 
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
         | declspecs_nots setspecs notype_initdecls ';'
-               { current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+               { POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_ts setspecs initdecls ';'
-               { current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+               { POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs ';'
          { shadow_tag ($1); }
        | error ';'
@@ -378,7 +397,7 @@ datadef:
 fndef:
          declspecs_ts setspecs declarator
                { if (! start_function (current_declspecs, $3,
-                                       prefix_attributes))
+                                       all_prefix_attributes))
                    YYERROR1;
                }
          old_style_parm_decls
@@ -387,16 +406,12 @@ fndef:
                { DECL_SOURCE_FILE (current_function_decl) = $7;
                  DECL_SOURCE_LINE (current_function_decl) = $8;
                  finish_function (0); 
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_ts setspecs declarator error
-               { current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+               { POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_nots setspecs notype_declarator
                { if (! start_function (current_declspecs, $3,
-                                       prefix_attributes))
+                                       all_prefix_attributes))
                    YYERROR1;
                }
          old_style_parm_decls
@@ -405,16 +420,12 @@ fndef:
                { DECL_SOURCE_FILE (current_function_decl) = $7;
                  DECL_SOURCE_LINE (current_function_decl) = $8;
                  finish_function (0); 
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_nots setspecs notype_declarator error
-               { current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+               { POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | setspecs notype_declarator
                { if (! start_function (NULL_TREE, $2,
-                                       prefix_attributes))
+                                       all_prefix_attributes))
                    YYERROR1;
                }
          old_style_parm_decls
@@ -423,13 +434,9 @@ fndef:
                { DECL_SOURCE_FILE (current_function_decl) = $6;
                  DECL_SOURCE_LINE (current_function_decl) = $7;
                  finish_function (0); 
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | setspecs notype_declarator error
-               { current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+               { POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        ;
 
 identifier:
@@ -800,13 +807,9 @@ datadecls:
    style parm.  */
 datadecl:
        declspecs_ts_nosa setspecs initdecls ';'
-               { current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+               { POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_nots_nosa setspecs notype_initdecls ';'
-               { current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);      
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+               { POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_ts_nosa ';'
                { shadow_tag_warned ($1, 1);
                  pedwarn ("empty declaration"); }
@@ -829,16 +832,15 @@ lineno_decl:
    for the sake of parm declarations nested in function declarators.  */
 setspecs: /* empty */
                { pending_xref_error ();
-                 declspec_stack = tree_cons (prefix_attributes,
-                                             current_declspecs,
-                                             declspec_stack);
+                 PUSH_DECLSPEC_STACK;
                  split_specs_attrs ($<ttype>0,
-                                    &current_declspecs, &prefix_attributes); }
+                                    &current_declspecs, &prefix_attributes);
+                 all_prefix_attributes = prefix_attributes; }
        ;
 
 /* ??? Yuck.  See maybe_setattrs.  */
 setattrs: /* empty */
-               { prefix_attributes = chainon (prefix_attributes, $<ttype>0); }
+               { all_prefix_attributes = chainon ($<ttype>0, all_prefix_attributes); }
        ;
 
 maybe_setattrs:
@@ -854,23 +856,22 @@ maybe_setattrs:
          maybe_attribute setattrs
        ;
 
+/* Possibly attributes after a comma, which should reset all_prefix_attributes
+   to prefix_attributes with these ones chained on the front.  */
+maybe_resetattrs:
+               { all_prefix_attributes = prefix_attributes; }
+         maybe_setattrs
+       ;
+
 decl:
        declspecs_ts setspecs initdecls ';'
-               { current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+               { POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_nots setspecs notype_initdecls ';'
-               { current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+               { POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_ts setspecs nested_function
-               { current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+               { POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_nots setspecs notype_nested_function
-               { current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+               { POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs ';'
                { shadow_tag ($1); }
        | extension decl
@@ -1347,7 +1348,7 @@ maybe_type_quals_setattrs:
                  split_specs_attrs ($1, &specs, &attrs);
                  /* ??? Yuck.  See maybe_setattrs.  */
                  if (attrs != NULL_TREE)
-                   prefix_attributes = chainon (prefix_attributes, attrs);
+                   all_prefix_attributes = chainon (attrs, all_prefix_attributes);
                  $$ = specs; }
        ;
 
@@ -1416,12 +1417,12 @@ end ifobjc
 
 initdecls:
        initdcl
-       | initdecls ',' maybe_setattrs initdcl
+       | initdecls ',' maybe_resetattrs initdcl
        ;
 
 notype_initdecls:
        notype_initdcl
-       | notype_initdecls ',' maybe_setattrs notype_initdcl
+       | notype_initdecls ',' maybe_resetattrs notype_initdcl
        ;
 
 maybeasm:
@@ -1436,7 +1437,7 @@ maybeasm:
 initdcl:
          declarator maybeasm maybe_attribute '='
                { $<ttype>$ = start_decl ($1, current_declspecs, 1,
-                                         chainon ($3, prefix_attributes));
+                                         chainon ($3, all_prefix_attributes));
                  start_init ($<ttype>$, $2, global_bindings_p ()); }
          init
 /* Note how the declaration of the variable is in effect while its init is parsed! */
@@ -1444,7 +1445,7 @@ initdcl:
                  finish_decl ($<ttype>5, $6, $2); }
        | declarator maybeasm maybe_attribute
                { tree d = start_decl ($1, current_declspecs, 0,
-                                      chainon ($3, prefix_attributes));
+                                      chainon ($3, all_prefix_attributes));
                  finish_decl (d, NULL_TREE, $2); 
                 }
        ;
@@ -1452,7 +1453,7 @@ initdcl:
 notype_initdcl:
          notype_declarator maybeasm maybe_attribute '='
                { $<ttype>$ = start_decl ($1, current_declspecs, 1,
-                                         chainon ($3, prefix_attributes));
+                                         chainon ($3, all_prefix_attributes));
                  start_init ($<ttype>$, $2, global_bindings_p ()); }
          init
 /* Note how the declaration of the variable is in effect while its init is parsed! */
@@ -1460,7 +1461,7 @@ notype_initdcl:
                  finish_decl ($<ttype>5, $6, $2); }
        | notype_declarator maybeasm maybe_attribute
                { tree d = start_decl ($1, current_declspecs, 0,
-                                      chainon ($3, prefix_attributes));
+                                      chainon ($3, all_prefix_attributes));
                  finish_decl (d, NULL_TREE, $2); }
        ;
 /* the * rules are dummies to accept the Apollo extended syntax
@@ -1594,7 +1595,7 @@ nested_function:
 
                  push_function_context ();
                  if (! start_function (current_declspecs, $1,
-                                       prefix_attributes))
+                                       all_prefix_attributes))
                    {
                      pop_function_context ();
                      YYERROR1;
@@ -1624,7 +1625,7 @@ notype_nested_function:
 
                  push_function_context ();
                  if (! start_function (current_declspecs, $1,
-                                       prefix_attributes))
+                                       all_prefix_attributes))
                    {
                      pop_function_context ();
                      YYERROR1;
@@ -1848,9 +1849,7 @@ end ifobjc
 component_decl:
          declspecs_nosc_ts setspecs components
                { $$ = $3;
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_nosc_ts setspecs save_filename save_lineno
                {
                  /* Support for unnamed structs or unions as members of 
@@ -1860,15 +1859,10 @@ component_decl:
                    pedwarn ("ISO C doesn't support unnamed structs/unions");
 
                  $$ = grokfield($3, $4, NULL, current_declspecs, NULL_TREE);
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack);
-               }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_nosc_nots setspecs components_notype
                { $$ = $3;
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_nosc_nots
                { if (pedantic)
                    pedwarn ("ISO C forbids member declarations with no members");
@@ -1883,40 +1877,40 @@ component_decl:
 
 components:
          component_declarator
-       | components ',' maybe_setattrs component_declarator
+       | components ',' maybe_resetattrs component_declarator
                { $$ = chainon ($1, $4); }
        ;
 
 components_notype:
          component_notype_declarator
-       | components_notype ',' maybe_setattrs component_notype_declarator
+       | components_notype ',' maybe_resetattrs component_notype_declarator
                { $$ = chainon ($1, $4); }
        ;
 
 component_declarator:
          save_filename save_lineno declarator maybe_attribute
                { $$ = grokfield ($1, $2, $3, current_declspecs, NULL_TREE);
-                 decl_attributes (&$$, chainon ($4, prefix_attributes), 0); }
+                 decl_attributes (&$$, chainon ($4, all_prefix_attributes), 0); }
        | save_filename save_lineno
          declarator ':' expr_no_commas maybe_attribute
                { $$ = grokfield ($1, $2, $3, current_declspecs, $5);
-                 decl_attributes (&$$, chainon ($6, prefix_attributes), 0); }
+                 decl_attributes (&$$, chainon ($6, all_prefix_attributes), 0); }
        | save_filename save_lineno ':' expr_no_commas maybe_attribute
                { $$ = grokfield ($1, $2, NULL_TREE, current_declspecs, $4);
-                 decl_attributes (&$$, chainon ($5, prefix_attributes), 0); }
+                 decl_attributes (&$$, chainon ($5, all_prefix_attributes), 0); }
        ;
 
 component_notype_declarator:
          save_filename save_lineno notype_declarator maybe_attribute
                { $$ = grokfield ($1, $2, $3, current_declspecs, NULL_TREE);
-                 decl_attributes (&$$, chainon ($4, prefix_attributes), 0); }
+                 decl_attributes (&$$, chainon ($4, all_prefix_attributes), 0); }
        | save_filename save_lineno
          notype_declarator ':' expr_no_commas maybe_attribute
                { $$ = grokfield ($1, $2, $3, current_declspecs, $5);
-                 decl_attributes (&$$, chainon ($6, prefix_attributes), 0); }
+                 decl_attributes (&$$, chainon ($6, all_prefix_attributes), 0); }
        | save_filename save_lineno ':' expr_no_commas maybe_attribute
                { $$ = grokfield ($1, $2, NULL_TREE, current_declspecs, $4);
-                 decl_attributes (&$$, chainon ($5, prefix_attributes), 0); }
+                 decl_attributes (&$$, chainon ($5, all_prefix_attributes), 0); }
        ;
 
 /* We chain the enumerators in reverse order.
@@ -1966,15 +1960,15 @@ absdcl_maybe_attribute:   /* absdcl maybe_attribute, but not just attributes */
        /* empty */
                { $$ = build_tree_list (build_tree_list (current_declspecs,
                                                         NULL_TREE),
-                                       prefix_attributes); }
+                                       all_prefix_attributes); }
        | absdcl1
                { $$ = build_tree_list (build_tree_list (current_declspecs,
                                                         $1),
-                                       prefix_attributes); }
+                                       all_prefix_attributes); }
        | absdcl1_noea attributes
                { $$ = build_tree_list (build_tree_list (current_declspecs,
                                                         $1),
-                                       chainon ($2, prefix_attributes)); }
+                                       chainon ($2, all_prefix_attributes)); }
        ;
 
 absdcl1:  /* a nonempty absolute declarator */
@@ -2564,35 +2558,25 @@ parm:
          declspecs_ts setspecs parm_declarator maybe_attribute
                { $$ = build_tree_list (build_tree_list (current_declspecs,
                                                         $3),
-                                       chainon ($4, prefix_attributes));
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                                       chainon ($4, all_prefix_attributes));
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_ts setspecs notype_declarator maybe_attribute
                { $$ = build_tree_list (build_tree_list (current_declspecs,
                                                         $3),
-                                       chainon ($4, prefix_attributes)); 
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                                       chainon ($4, all_prefix_attributes)); 
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_ts setspecs absdcl_maybe_attribute
                { $$ = $3;
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_nots setspecs notype_declarator maybe_attribute
                { $$ = build_tree_list (build_tree_list (current_declspecs,
                                                         $3),
-                                       chainon ($4, prefix_attributes));
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                                       chainon ($4, all_prefix_attributes));
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
 
        | declspecs_nots setspecs absdcl_maybe_attribute
                { $$ = $3;
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        ;
 
 /* The first parm, which must suck attributes from off the top of the parser
@@ -2601,40 +2585,31 @@ firstparm:
          declspecs_ts_nosa setspecs_fp parm_declarator maybe_attribute
                { $$ = build_tree_list (build_tree_list (current_declspecs,
                                                         $3),
-                                       chainon ($4, prefix_attributes));
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                                       chainon ($4, all_prefix_attributes));
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_ts_nosa setspecs_fp notype_declarator maybe_attribute
                { $$ = build_tree_list (build_tree_list (current_declspecs,
                                                         $3),
-                                       chainon ($4, prefix_attributes)); 
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                                       chainon ($4, all_prefix_attributes)); 
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_ts_nosa setspecs_fp absdcl_maybe_attribute
                { $$ = $3;
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_nots_nosa setspecs_fp notype_declarator maybe_attribute
                { $$ = build_tree_list (build_tree_list (current_declspecs,
                                                         $3),
-                                       chainon ($4, prefix_attributes));
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                                       chainon ($4, all_prefix_attributes));
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
 
        | declspecs_nots_nosa setspecs_fp absdcl_maybe_attribute
                { $$ = $3;
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        ;
 
 setspecs_fp:
          setspecs
-               { prefix_attributes = chainon (prefix_attributes, $<ttype>-2); }
+               { prefix_attributes = chainon (prefix_attributes, $<ttype>-2);
+                 all_prefix_attributes = prefix_attributes; }
        ;
 
 /* This is used in a function definition
@@ -2918,14 +2893,10 @@ ivar_decls:
 ivar_decl:
        declspecs_nosc_ts setspecs ivars
                { $$ = $3;
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_nosc_nots setspecs ivars
                { $$ = $3;
-                 current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+                 POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | error
                { $$ = NULL_TREE; }
        ;
@@ -2934,7 +2905,7 @@ ivars:
          /* empty */
                { $$ = NULL_TREE; }
        | ivar_declarator
-       | ivars ',' maybe_setattrs ivar_declarator
+       | ivars ',' maybe_resetattrs ivar_declarator
        ;
 
 ivar_declarator:
@@ -3081,9 +3052,7 @@ mydecls:
 
 mydecl:
        declspecs_ts setspecs myparms ';'
-               { current_declspecs = TREE_VALUE (declspec_stack);
-                 prefix_attributes = TREE_PURPOSE (declspec_stack);
-                 declspec_stack = TREE_CHAIN (declspec_stack); }
+               { POP_DECLSPEC_STACK; }
        | declspecs_ts ';'
                { shadow_tag ($1); }
        | declspecs_nots ';'
@@ -3104,11 +3073,11 @@ myparm:
          parm_declarator maybe_attribute
                { $$ = build_tree_list (build_tree_list (current_declspecs,
                                                         $1),
-                                       chainon ($2, prefix_attributes)); }
+                                       chainon ($2, all_prefix_attributes)); }
        | notype_declarator maybe_attribute
                { $$ = build_tree_list (build_tree_list (current_declspecs,
                                                         $1),
-                                       chainon ($2, prefix_attributes)); }
+                                       chainon ($2, all_prefix_attributes)); }
        | absdcl_maybe_attribute
                { $$ = $1; }
        ;

diff --git a/gcc/doc/extend.texi b/gcc/doc/extend.texi
index f08be3b426ecf31c4594215995c8bb2124f6a6a4..74dd33effd72b64f85881beeef37c05c80b7f5ec 100644 (file)
--- a/gcc/doc/extend.texi
+++ b/gcc/doc/extend.texi
@@ -2188,15 +2188,12 @@ other specifiers or qualifiers.
 An attribute specifier list may appear immediately before a declarator
 (other than the first) in a comma-separated list of declarators in a
 declaration of more than one identifier using a single list of
-specifiers and qualifiers.  At present, such attribute specifiers apply
-not only to the identifier before whose declarator they appear, but to
-all subsequent identifiers declared in that declaration, but in future
-they may apply only to that single identifier.  For example, in
+specifiers and qualifiers.  Such attribute specifiers apply
+only to the identifier before whose declarator they appear.  For example, in
 @code{__attribute__((noreturn)) void d0 (void),
 __attribute__((format(printf, 1, 2))) d1 (const char *, ...), d2
 (void)}, the @code{noreturn} attribute applies to all the functions
-declared; the @code{format} attribute should only apply to @code{d1},
-but at present applies to @code{d2} as well (and so causes an error).
+declared; the @code{format} attribute only applies to @code{d1}.
 
 An attribute specifier list may appear immediately before the comma,
 @code{=} or semicolon terminating the declaration of an identifier other
@@ -2227,12 +2224,10 @@ ignored.
 
 An attribute specifier list may appear at the start of a nested
 declarator.  At present, there are some limitations in this usage: the
-attributes apply to the identifier declared, and to all subsequent
-identifiers declared in that declaration (if it includes a
-comma-separated list of declarators), rather than to a specific
+attributes apply to the identifier declared, rather than to a specific
 declarator.  When attribute specifiers follow the @code{*} of a pointer
-declarator, they must presently follow any type qualifiers present, and
-cannot be mixed with them.  The following describes intended future
+declarator, they may be mixed with any type qualifiers present.
+The following describes intended future
 semantics which make this syntax more useful only.  It will make the
 most sense if you are familiar with the formal specification of
 declarators in the ISO C standard.

diff --git a/gcc/testsuite/ChangeLog b/gcc/testsuite/ChangeLog
index d2f2a670a90983820cdab44f90c5593f20219071..5d8d2dc3102672bbf6678bb3e20209f73224d318 100644 (file)
--- a/gcc/testsuite/ChangeLog
+++ b/gcc/testsuite/ChangeLog
@@ -1,3 +1,8 @@
+2001-07-17  Joseph S. Myers  <jsm28@cam.ac.uk>
+
+       * gcc.c-torture/compile/20010714-1.c, gcc.dg/format/attr-4.c: New
+       tests.
+
 2001-07-17  Peter Schmid  <schmid@snake.iap.physik.tu-darmstadt.de>
 
        * g++.old-deja/g++.robertl/eb130.C: Include the correct header file.

diff --git a/gcc/testsuite/gcc.c-torture/compile/20010714-1.c b/gcc/testsuite/gcc.c-torture/compile/20010714-1.c
new file mode 100644 (file)
index 0000000..fc4bdba
--- /dev/null
+++ b/gcc/testsuite/gcc.c-torture/compile/20010714-1.c
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+/* Test that prefix attributes after a comma only apply to a single
+   declared object or function.  */
+/* Origin: Joseph Myers <jsm28@cam.ac.uk>.  */
+
+__attribute__((noreturn)) void d0 (void), __attribute__((format(printf, 1, 2))) d1 (const char *, ...), d2 (void);

diff --git a/gcc/testsuite/gcc.dg/format/attr-4.c b/gcc/testsuite/gcc.dg/format/attr-4.c
new file mode 100644 (file)
index 0000000..ef50c49
--- /dev/null
+++ b/gcc/testsuite/gcc.dg/format/attr-4.c
@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
+/* Test for format attributes: test use of __attribute__
+   in prefix attributes.  */
+/* Origin: Joseph Myers <jsm28@cam.ac.uk> */
+/* { dg-do compile } */
+/* { dg-options "-std=gnu99 -Wformat" } */
+
+#include "format.h"
+
+extern __attribute__((format(printf, 1, 2))) void tformatprintf0 (const char *, ...);
+extern void __attribute__((format(printf, 1, 2))) tformatprintf1 (const char *, ...);
+extern void foo (void), __attribute__((format(printf, 1, 2))) tformatprintf2 (const char *, ...);
+extern __attribute__((noreturn)) void bar (void), __attribute__((format(printf, 1, 2))) tformatprintf3 (const char *, ...);
+
+void
+baz (int i, int *ip, double d)
+{
+  tformatprintf0 ("%d", i);
+  tformatprintf0 ("%"); /* { dg-warning "format" "attribute format printf case 0" } */
+  tformatprintf1 ("%d", i);
+  tformatprintf1 ("%"); /* { dg-warning "format" "attribute format printf case 1" } */
+  tformatprintf2 ("%d", i);
+  tformatprintf2 ("%"); /* { dg-warning "format" "attribute format printf case 2" } */
+  tformatprintf3 ("%d", i);
+  tformatprintf3 ("%"); /* { dg-warning "format" "attribute format printf case 3" } */
+}